*Tournament Champions
2023 - Trinity University
2022 - Trinity University
2021 - Trinity University
2020 - Austin College 
2019 - Texas Lutheran University
2018 - Trinity University
2017 - Trinity University 
2016 - Trinity University
2015 - Southwestern University
2014 - Texas Lutheran University
2013 - Trinity University
2012 - Centre College
2011 - DePauw University
2010 - DePauw University
2009 - Oglethorpe University
2008 - DePauw University
2007 - DePauw University
2006 - DePauw University
2005 - Trinity University
2004 - DePauw University
2003 - Trinity University

*The SCAC did not begin conducting a postseason conference tournament until the 2002-03 season.

+Regular Season Champions
2022-23 - Trinity University
2021-22 - Trinity University
2020-21 - No SCAC Regular Season Champion with COVID-19 Schedule
2019-20 - Trinity University 
2018-19 - Trinity University
2017-18 - (Co-champs) Austin College, Trinity University
2016-17 - Trinity Univeristy
2015-16 - Trinity University
2014-15 - (Tri-champs) Southwestern University, Texas Lutheran University, Trinity University
2013-14 - Texas Lutheran University
2012-13 - Trinity University
2011-12 - Centre College (East Division) | Southwestern University (West Division)
2010-11 - DePauw University (East Division) | Hendrix College (West Division)
2009-10 - DePauw University (East Division) | Hendrix College (West Division)
2008-09 - Oglethorpe University (East Division) | Trinity University (West Division)
2007-08 - DePauw University (East Division) | Trinity University (West Division)
2006-07 - DePauw University
2005-06 - DePauw University
2004-05 - DePauw University
2003-04 - (Co-champs) DePauw University, Trinity University
2002-03 - Trinity University
2001-02 - DePauw University
2000-01 - (Tri-champs) Centre College, DePauw University, University of the South-Sewanee
1999-00 - (Co-champs) DePauw University, Hendrix College
1998-99 - DePauw University
1997-98 - Southwestern University
1996-97 - Hendrix College
1995-96 - (Co-champs) Hendrix College, Millsaps College
1994-95 - Trinity University
1993-94 - Centre College
1992-93 - Centre College
1991-92 - Centre College

+Once the SCAC moved to a postseason tournament format in 2002-03, the league ceased to formally recognize regular season champions again until the 2014-15 season.