| Year | Champion | Conference Record | Overall Record | Championship Site |
| 2023 | University of St. Thomas (Tex.) | 17-3 | 33-10 | San Antonio, Texas |
| 2022 | Texas Lutheran University | 21-0 | 45-6 | Irving, Texas |
| 2021 | Texas Lutheran University | 18-0 | 36-6 | Kerrville, Texas |
| 2020 | Tournament Cancelled Due To Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | ^Texas Lutheran Univeristy | 22-1 | 40-8 | Shreveport, La. |
| 2018 | Texas Lutheran Univeristy | 19-0 | 38-6 | Georgetown, Texas |
| 2017 | Texas Lutheran Univeristy | 22-0 | 38-6 | Seguin, Texas |
| 2016 | Texas Lutheran Univeristy | 23-1 | 43-5 | San Antonio, Texas |
| 2015 | Texas Lutheran University | 23-0 | 37-6 | Kerrville, Texas |
| 2014 | Texas Lutheran University | 21-1 | 33-8 | Seguin, Texas |
| 2013 | Southwestern (Tex.) University | 13-3 | 34-13 | Irving, Texas |
| 2012 | Birmingham-Southern College | 15-1 | 36-11 | Jackson, Tenn. |
| 2011 | DePauw University | 10-4 | 32-11-1 | Greencastle, Ind. |
| 2010 | Southwestern (Tex.) University | 10-4 | 33-13 | Conway, Ark. |
| 2009 | DePauw University | 14-0 | 32-9 | San Antonio, Texas |
| 2008 | DePauw University | 8-0 | 40-4 | Danville, Ky. |
| 2007 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 9-3 | 26-12 | San Antonio, Texas |
| 2006 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 12-0 | 29-14 | Sewanee, Tenn. |
| 2005 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 9-3 | 28-22 | Conway, Ark. |
| 2004 | Sewanee-The University of the South | 6-6 | 20-21 | Panthersville, Ga. |
| 2003 | Millsaps College | 11-1 | 28-11 | Terre Haute, Ind. |
| 2002 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 7-1 | 27-16 | Jackson, Miss. |
| 2001 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 17-1 | 29-10 | Greencastle, Ind. |
| 2000 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 11-1 | 18-19 | Memphis, Tenn. |
| 1999 | Trinity (Tex.) University | 4-0 | 17-16 | San Antonio, Texas |
| ^National Champions | ||||